zimmytws/iStock through Getty Pictures
Funding Thesis
Signed into legislation in 2010, the ACA has ushered in important modifications to how People obtain well being care. One space of focus was implementing a value-based strategy to healthcare supply away from volume-based fee-for-service fee fashions. Since then, the CMS (Facilities for Medicare & Medicaid Companies) has been experimenting with totally different fashions with totally different insurers, healthcare suppliers, and state authorities our bodies. Danielle Cattel, an assistant professor at Erasmus College, studied 18 of those initiatives and located one commonality: a give attention to Major Care. This concept underpins the surge of the deal exercise within the Major Care market, manifested in Amazon’s (AMZN) acquisition of One Medical (ONEM), CVS’s (CVS) acquisition of Signify (SGFY), Walgreens (WBA) acquisition of Village MD and the wave of recent managed care startups lately going public, together with Clover Well being (CLOV), and Alignment Healthcare (ALHC), each using preventive care as a technique to decrease prices. The rationale behind the coverage framework is straightforward: by investing in main care, the healthcare system might cut back dearer hospitalization.
This deal exercise mirrors the dimensions of the chance the CMS’s fee mannequin transition affords. However the true query is, does agilon well being (NYSE:AGL) present such an opportunity? I do not suppose so. The most well liked asset within the healthcare market at this time is main care services, and whereas AGL runs partnerships with 17 doctor teams, spawning 2,200 main care docs, it would not personal the underlying belongings, lowering its enchantment as an M&A goal, undermining its proposition in comparison with the likes of (AMED) and LifeStance Well being (LFST), main healthcare suppliers, who personal the underlying belongings, and derive nearly all of earnings from Medicare and Medicaid packages.
One cannot discover significant worth when judging AGL’s enterprise mannequin on its deserves. Working a hybrid breed of a re-insurance firm and outsourcing enterprise, it lacks a aggressive edge, taking a lot threat for little return. The corporate has limitless loss publicity for sufferers’ medical bills, taking the danger from Humana (HUM) and UnitedHealth (UNH) for a fraction of earnings beneath risk-sharing agreements, with PCPs incomes many of the earnings. AGL additionally offers outsourcing actions, sustaining the billing duties on behalf of its suppliers.
Income Tendencies
Buyers ought to pay attention to a number of developments shaping the healthcare business – particularly for corporations like AGL, which focuses its enterprise on the Medicare market. These developments are driving modifications throughout the complete healthcare system, together with how suppliers ship care and the way they’re paid for that care. Nonetheless, regardless of the burden of healthcare expenditure on public budgets, I do not consider that reducing these providers is a politically viable choice for elected officers or candidates operating for workplace. The truth is, the Wholesome Individuals 2030 initiative expanded nationwide healthcare targets, as did the 2020 and 2010 initiatives earlier than that.
AGL earns a capitated income per Medicare member coated. Because it creates new partnerships, its income will enhance, together with lives coated. Given its scope specializing in US seniors, its income comes from two sources 1) insurance coverage corporations providing Medicare Benefit and a pair of) the CMS beneath the Direct Contracting program. Thus, the corporate stands to learn from demographic developments within the US because the child boomer era ages and turn out to be eligible for Medicare.
Probably the most important progress driver is intra-state and inter-state enlargement via new supplier partnerships. Presently, the corporate operates in seven states, up from 5 final yr. Just lately, it introduced new partnerships in new states, together with Maine, Minnesota, South Carolina, and Tennessee, including almost 1 / 4 of 1,000,000 lives to its platform beginning in January 2023.
Two elements contribute to the corporate’s capacity to check in partnerships. First, management expertise manifested within the capacity to construct and preserve partnerships with present and new PCPs and payors (insurance coverage corporations). Steve Promote is the previous CEO of Well being Internet, Centene’s (CNC) largest subsidiary. The board contains business leaders with deep connections and experience, corresponding to Dr. Invoice Wulf, the Chairman of America’s Doctor Teams, a medical affiliation with 300 institutional members. I consider that AGL’s administration expertise is essential to its success as the corporate continues to develop and develop past its present markets into further states.
Second, the corporate affords PCPs and insurers a beautiful deal, bearing many of the threat for a small fraction of earnings. For instance, it caps insurers’ publicity to the agreed capitated month-to-month fee per member. In distinction, its threat publicity to medical bills is limitless if the enrollees want further care. Suppose its PCP companions achieve reducing well being bills. In that case, it solely shares a fraction of earnings whereas sustaining managerial duties corresponding to assortment, billing, liquidity help, squeezing margins, and underpinning our maintain score.
Margin Tendencies
There is no such thing as a doubt in my thoughts that AGL can generate progress for the explanations acknowledged above. Nonetheless, there’s nonetheless a query about valuation. The corporate’s enterprise mannequin is exclusive, capitalizing on CMS’s value-based care initiatives to decrease healthcare spending. Nonetheless, it lacks a aggressive edge. Many insurance coverage corporations function related risk-sharing packages instantly with their suppliers’ networks. Furthermore, the absence of the economics of scale limits income progress advantages. The variable prices per enrollee are excessive.
Lastly, one can not help however suppose that the insurance coverage business, together with hybrid fashions corresponding to AGL, is digging its grave. The Division of Housing and Human Companies “HSS” units the Medicare reimbursement charges primarily based on common care expenditure (at the moment standing round $10,000 on common per enrollee per yr.) The utmost gross margin allowed by insurance coverage corporations is 15% – 20% (relying on dimension). Nonetheless, to encourage the adoption of value-based care practices, the CMS, beneath some packages, permits insurers to maintain no matter financial savings they obtain past this gross margin vary. Suppose the business succeeds in altering customary procedures and reducing nationwide common care expenditure. In that case, the HSS will possible reply by reducing its base reimbursement charges. That is the entire level of those initiatives. Thus, I consider that, in some sense, AGL’s quest to develop margins is like pursuing a mirage, no less than in the long term.
Abstract
AGL’s prospects hinge on its capacity to decrease the price of look after its members and preserve them wholesome (as indicated by the pattern in healthcare utilization metrics). To this point, so good. Margins have been enhancing, verifying the optimistic relationship between ACA-aligned care and value reductions. One problem, nevertheless, is sustaining optimistic margin momentum because it expands its PCP partnerships. Ought to it achieve this efficiently, the corporate might hit a significant milestone in its progress story. Nonetheless, execution dangers are exacerbated by excessive variable prices, structurally low margins, and limitless draw back publicity to sufferers’ well being care prices as a reinsurer of Medicare Benefit insurance coverage members. In the long term, margins will possible be capped by a dynamic base fee set by the HSS. For now, the value stage is just too excessive, given its challenges.
